Fit Recovery

Home » Cycling » Banning Parents from Driving Kids to School? Now that may not be the worst idea ever…

Banning Parents from Driving Kids to School? Now that may not be the worst idea ever…

March 2017
« Feb   Apr »

When I was 13 years-old, my daughter’s age, I would ride my bike to school when it was nice out.  If memory serves, it was ten or twelve miles if we went the long (paved) way, and eight if we took the shortcut and used dirt roads.  The only trick was the shortcut required we ride on the side of an exceptionally busy 55 mph paved road for a mile.  We didn’t like that and the paved option led us right to the back entrance of our middle school (seventh grade).  At just 13, I had freedom.  Today, we live just five miles from my daughter’s school, on roads much less dangerous that those I rode to school on, yet she’s never once ridden a bike to school.

Jamie Beach at Bike Radar recently wrote a report that looked at how they do things in the Netherlands, where Dutch kids regularly ride their bikes to school and according to studies, their kids are vastly happier than those of the US, UK, and Germany.  I’ll let Jamie take it from there:

But humour me here, let’s look at all the benefits we’d enjoy IF we could somehow take all those cars off the road and away from schools…

First, there would be far less congestion and traffic fumes, particularly around schools. If you live in a city, you’re probably familiar with that nasty taste in the back of your throat that indicates air quality is not what it should be. The World Health Organisation says it’s a mass killer, responsible for over 3m preventable deaths worldwide annually due to heart disease, asthma and lung cancer. In fact, the EU’s five most prosperous economies (Germany, France, the UK, Spain and Italy) all fail the WHO’s recommended limits for air pollution.

Second, parents would insist on better cycling infrastructure. I know, it’s scary to think that our children would be out there, battling road traffic. But we can accompany them ourselves, and teach them how to navigate crossings. This seems to be the Dutch approach, a cycling culture that’s passed down from parent to child. Of course, if you live next to a motorway or freeway then maybe there’s just no way your child can safely cycle to school, and the school bus could be a better option. But for most of us, segregated cycle lanes would be an excellent option.

Third, kids would get more exercise – which has been proven by scientists to improve concentration and cognitive mapping in the developing brain. A 2012 Danish study found that kids who cycled or walked to school, rather than being driven, performed measurably better on tasks demanding concentration. A separate US study has found that children growing up in traffic-heavy neighbourhoods have a much more negative attitude towards their environment, and a weaker ability to accurately map it.

As mentioned above, it will also give children that crucial sense of independence, essential to life happiness. These things do matter. If young people feel they can ride to school, go visit friends when they want, or just get out and explore their neighbourhood, they’ll be happier, and parents will feel less like chauffeurs.

Let’s not forget, either, that cycling is a useful life skill – just as Dutch parents cycle everywhere themselves, it would be great if more adults in Britain, the US and Australia got on their bikes. It frustrates me just how car-dependent we’ve become here in the UK, sold on the promise of convenience and thrills, when the reality is our roads are absurdly clogged and road rage abounds. And the solution isn’t bigger roads, that’s a very short-term answer to the problem.

Finally, it’s so much cheaper to cycle everywhere; just think of all the money we’d save on petrol and public transport. Sure, the weather’s sometimes against us, and there could be hills to deal with, but both can be tackled with a bit of determination and the right gear. As the authors of my book on Dutch kids found out, it’s important to foster a bit of resilience and grit – this is often cited as a key factor in happiness later in life.

I like his thinking – and equally interesting as his points, if my kids rode to school and home, they’d be quicker, by as much as 40 minutes each way, than if they take the bus.

What if there was a massive influx of cyclists on our roads?  All of a sudden, bam!  Tomorrow there’s a 40% increase in cyclists.  Politicians were actually pressured into adding that nice 2′ shoulder (which, in turn, makes the roads last longer because the bigger trucks aren’t constantly riding right on the edge of the road/lane).

I do know one thing for certain, I never got a bike smile on the couch:





  1. This is a great idea! When I was a kid, we walked to elementary school, until we learned how to ride bikes. Then, from there on out, we rode our bikes……rain or shine!

    We had this neat invention…a raincoat….which when worn, prevented you from getting wet…for the most part and allowed you to ride your bike to school.

    Plus, riding your bike you got to see and feel the rooster-tail from the back wheel…as the first thing you did as a “cool kid”, was to remove the rear fender of your bike, if so equipped.

    This is yet another example of, to quote George Carlin, the “feline-a-facation” (cleaned-up version), of todays youth.

    Our son rides his bike everywhere and I can’t wait until he rides by himself on the main roads. He has developed riding skills here in the neighborhood and with me on some rides to adjoining neighborhoods.

    He enjoys his independence……..and if more parents would allow their kids to experience that, they would find, that as parents, they would have more time for themselves…which can be a good thing! 🙂

  2. Used to cycle all over when I was young, went to school by bike 3 or 4 miles each way, partially on busy main roads too. Used to disappear from the house with other kids and cycle a few miles of an evening or weekend to make adventure tracks on the old bomb sites in Liverpool. I think I’ve still got that spirit too. I’m surprised by the number of cyclists who just repeat the same routes nearby.

  3. I ride to school in primary, as it was only 3-4 miles on shared path. If the infrastructure is there it helps! I wouldn’t have ridden (or been allowed) if I had to be on the fast and busy main road.

  4. AMEN!!! As a card carrying member of a city commission to promote cycling and cycling safety in my little Chicago burb, I have to applaud the notion of banning parents from driving their kids to school.

    My commission coordinates a “Bike To School Day” at the two elementary schools in our city. We provide extra crossing guides, police escorts (including our bike patrol officers on their bikes), plus incentives like an extra recess that day for the class with the most participants. We sponsor a bike safety “rodeo” once a year that provides a free safety inspection and repairs for bikes (done by mechanics from a local bike shop), helmet fittings and giveaways, a free raffle for 25 brand spanking new bikes, a safety course that each participant can ride, pictures with our mayor, bike registrations, etc….

    You might think that the elementary school with the lowest income per capita would be the school with the most participants. It’s not even close, with a very minimal participation. The school on the “other side of town” has hundreds of students that participate each year!

  5. I think this would be amazing. It came up at one of the panel discussions yesterday and one of the main reasons parents give to not wanting to cycle with their children to school (or let their children cycle by themselves) is the amount of car traffic in their area. Yet, during the school run, the majority of that traffic is made up of parents driving their children to school!

    It baffles the mind, if they all tried it for one day, they’d see a huge difference immediately.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: